
Two former Cummins employees have pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit securities fraud over the company’s $3.7 billion Meritor acquisition. There are confidential negotiations, share purchases, messages and a hoped-for Tesla in the paperwork. For readers familiar with Employment Judge Seamus Sweeney, those admissions also invite a rather British comparison. First, however, the American proceedings deserve their moment, because the details are considerably better than anything a corporate communications department would have chosen.
According to the US Department of Justice, Fan “Jocelyn” Yang calculated in a WeChat exchange that the anticipated profits could buy a Tesla without a loan. Strip away the acquisition vocabulary and there is the little domestic ambition underneath: someone else’s confidential business information, converted into the prospect of a car on the drive. A finance plan with a rather unusual application process.
Cummins Insider Trading: The Guilty Pleas
Yang and her husband, Jing Tian, pleaded guilty in Washington, DC, on 15 September 2026. Their sentencing is scheduled for 15 January 2027. Each faces a maximum of five years in prison; that is the statutory ceiling reported by prosecutors, not a sentence already imposed. Both also agreed to forfeit profits traceable to the scheme.
The Securities and Exchange Commission identifies Yang as a former accountant in Cummins’ corporate development department and Tian as a former Cummins engineer. Its separate civil case, filed on 28 September, names the couple and four further defendants. The SEC alleges that confidential information travelled through a chain of personal contacts and that the four downstream traders collectively made more than $500,000. Those four consented to civil judgments without admitting the allegations. Their position should not be muddled with the couple’s criminal guilty pleas.
There is also a beautifully sour detail in The Indiana Lawyer’s reporting: the SEC alleges that Yang and Tian sold their own holdings at a loss before the announcement, while the downstream traders benefited afterwards. The information made it through the network more successfully than the originators’ investment strategy. Even with access to the inside track, they managed to find the fucking gravel.
Project Rose And The Private Car Fund
The SEC complaint says the renewed acquisition negotiations carried the code name Project Rose. Cummins had confidentiality and insider trading policies that applied to both employees. Those policies prohibited trading on confidential information about another company and passing it to someone else for that purpose. The written rules were there. The confidential project still found its way into private dealing.
According to the same complaint, Yang disclosed the trading to an in-house Cummins attorney in early February 2022 and described it as coincidental. Elsewhere, the SEC alleges that downstream participants discussed cover explanations and deleting messages. These are allegations in the civil complaint, rather than admissions by every person it names. Nevertheless, the contrast is striking: elaborate corporate confidentiality on one side, private conversations about how to explain the trades on the other.
Cummins itself is not a defendant in that SEC case. Its response to The Indiana Lawyer was brief: “The individuals are no longer employed by Cummins. We will not comment further on personnel or legal matters”. There is the communications department’s preferred exit: through the personnel door, with the company name left hanging on the coat hook.
Meanwhile, Cummins’ December 2023 response to its separate emissions settlement remains available for anyone collecting examples of corporate reassurance. The company said it had seen no evidence that anyone acted in bad faith. That statement concerned emissions, not this securities case, and it was a company statement rather than a new pronouncement from Jennifer Rumsey. Still, I suspect the phrase could do with a fucking holiday. It has worked hard.
The Seamus Sweeney Treatment
One read of Employment Judge Seamus Sweeney’s comments in my case and the defendants might start hoping for his intervention. The coward and his red pen are perhaps rather less bold when the organisation on the other side is the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Employment Judge Seamus Sweeney And Chris Paling’s Letter
Employment Judge Seamus Sweeney chaired the tribunal in my case, Thompson v Cummins Ltd, 2501831/2022. Paragraphs 94–95 address a letter dated 7 June 2022 that Gemma Penk attached to an email on 28 September. The tribunal accepted that Chris Paling had recreated it retrospectively. It said he did so “at the very least, to cover his own tracks”.
The tribunal also found that its substantive sick-pay information was accurate, that Paling believed he had sent an earlier letter, although he might not have done, and that the recreation caused me no disadvantage. It rejected my allegation of fraud as “a nonsense” and treated it as an extreme expression of my distrust of Cummins. Paling admitted recreating the letter; he did not admit the criminal offence of fraud.
That is the foundation of the criticism of Seamus Sweeney. The institutional manoeuvre is what interests me: a problem in an employer’s paperwork becomes a problem in the employee’s attitude. You arrive asking why the record looks like that. You leave reading an authoritative explanation of why your reaction is the more revealing feature. It is a marvellous way to tidy a desk without dealing with the shit on it.
Seamus Sweeney And The Difference Between Figures And History
A letter communicates more than the figures in its body. Its date, its origin and the circumstances in which it reaches someone also tell a story. An accurate account of an entitlement does not, by itself, establish that a particular communication existed earlier or was sent when its heading suggests. That distinction matters whenever an institution relies on its records to explain what it did.
Think of the ordinary reader receiving an old-looking letter during a dispute. The natural question is whether this is an existing record being retrieved or a new document being produced. Those are different things. Calling attention to the difference is not some exotic hobby enjoyed by the terminally suspicious. It is basic document reading. The date at the top has not been put there to fucking decorate the margins.
For me, Employment Judge Seamus Sweeney’s reasoning is objectionable because the accurate figures do so much work while the document’s history receives so much indulgence. I wanted that distinction taken seriously. Instead, the passage makes my insistence on it sound like a personal defect. The employer gets context; the employee gets character analysis. That is the asymmetry I am criticising. Maybe “Shameless” Sweeney was too busy drooling over the vastly experienced Miller and forgot what jurisdiction he was in.
Employment Judge Sweeney And The Fraud Question
There is a legal distinction here too. Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006 concerns a dishonest false representation, made knowing it is or might be untrue or misleading, with an intention to make a gain or cause loss or a risk of loss. Representations can be implied. The relevant gain or loss concerns money or other property. The Crown Prosecution Service’s guidance makes clear that an actual gain or loss need not occur.
Consequently, the absence of a completed financial loss does not, by itself, dispose of every possible fraud allegation. Equally, retrospective document creation does not, by itself, prove fraud: dishonesty, the representation and the required financial intention still have to be established. Those requirements are precisely why analysis matters. Neither an accusation nor a judicial eye-roll supplies the missing elements.
Employment Judge Sweeney could assess the evidence relevant to the employment claims. That did not turn the hearing into a criminal trial or his conclusion into a criminal acquittal. My criticism is of the reasoning and the contempt in its delivery on the page. I regard the leap from a disputed document’s provenance to the complainant’s supposed disposition as smug, complacent bollocks. A judge is entitled to reject an allegation. He should still explain the issue he is rejecting with care.
I also consulted Action Fraud through its live chat. On the facts I described, the response I received disagreed with Sweeney’s assessment. An awkward little complication for the supposed oracle of knowledge. In later proceedings, barrister Wendy Miller used my stated intention to report the conduct as part of an allegation that I had a propensity to resort to “extreme threats”, as an implication for witness intimidation.
Seamus Sweeney And The Cost Of Noticing
The American securities case and my employment case concern different conduct, different laws and different evidence. The comparison concerns the handling of uncomfortable facts. It asks what happens after an institution accepts that something occurred: whether the conduct receives sustained scrutiny, or whether attention migrates towards the temperament of the person who challenged it.
This is why Seamus Sweeney remains a subject for TCAP. A public judgment is an exercise of public authority. Its account of an individual can travel far beyond the hearing room, while the individual’s response is easily dismissed as the predictable noise of somebody who lost. That arrangement gives judges considerable editorial power over other people’s lives. It also makes close, persistent criticism of their published reasoning necessary.
I do not have to accept Seamus Sweeney’s portrait of me as the final explanation for my objections. Nor do I have to adopt the soothing vocabulary that makes institutional failures sound manageable. An employment tribunal judgment can be authoritative in its legal effect and still deserve a thorough public kicking for the way it reasons. The title on the door does not make the prose immune from examination.
In Washington, the case will proceed towards sentencing. At home, the question remains about a concrete document. The date at the top of a letter is part of what it tells its reader. If an institution has to explain why that date does not mean what it appears to mean, its first problem is the fucking letter. My tone can wait.
If the Seamus Sweeney treatment ever reaches Washington, the SEC would have an appropriate response:
“Stay in your fucking lane, pal”.
Off you fuck. Oh, and take your fucking red pen with you.
Lee Thompson – Founder, The Cummins Accountability Project
Sources
- US Department Of Justice: Yang And Tian’s Guilty Pleas And Scheduled Sentencing
- Securities And Exchange Commission: The Separate Civil Case And Consent Judgments
- SEC Civil Complaint: Project Rose, Confidentiality Policies, Trading And Alleged Concealment
- The Indiana Lawyer: Reporting On The Cummins Employees And The Company’s Response
- Cummins: December 2023 Statement On The Separate Emissions Settlement
- Thompson v Cummins Ltd: Written Reasons, Particularly Paragraphs 94–95
- Fraud Act 2006: Section 2, Fraud By False Representation
- Fraud Act 2006: Section 5, Gain And Loss
- Crown Prosecution Service: Guidance On Fraud And The Required Elements
- Courts And Tribunals Judiciary: Appointment Of James Peter (Seamus) “Shameless” Sweeney
- TCAP: Earlier Coverage Of Chris Paling And The Recreated Pay Letter
