Gunnercooke – The Fungus Years : Angus Menzies Trains The Other Fucking Side

Angus Menzies at gunnercooke gave the internet an employment-law webinar. Underneath it, however, a viewer left the sort of review that should make a marketing department quietly reach for the fucking fuse box. There are testimonials you put on the website. Then there are testimonials you read twice before checking who can see the video.

“Brilliant. Claimants will find it more useful than employers !”

That was @desertfox662, commenting beneath Angus’s session on defending whistleblowing claims. What a magnificent little service failure. The chef has explained the recipe, the customers can see into the kitchen, and someone at the other table is taking notes. TCAP would like to thank him for his contribution to public education.


Angus Menzies At Gunnercooke: The Training Is Public

Gunnercooke advertised Whistleblowing Claims and How to Defend Them on 22 November 2018. It named Angus as its employment law partner. The recording then reached YouTube on 14 January 2019. This is the same Angus whose later Horsfield Menzies commentary has repeatedly supplied TCAP with the operating manual.

His stated target is weak whistleblowing claims. He also urges employers to support genuine whistleblowers and tackle malpractice. The session interests TCAP because he explains the commercial choices so openly. A polished industry can spend a fortune making this stuff sound reassuring. Fungus just lifts the lid.

Our earlier gunnercooke history followed the firm’s client-account troubles. This series follows Angus’s own public advice. The distinction matters because the material here comes from the man himself. Nobody has had to reconstruct his commercial reasoning from a corporate press release. He has explained it to a camera.


The Embarrassing Bit

At around 44 minutes, Angus explains why an employer might concede that disclosures were made when denying them would be difficult. That narrows the defence, but it can avoid an embarrassing public argument. The fight can then concentrate on whether those disclosures caused the treatment or dismissal. The concession concerns the disclosures being made, not whether their allegations were true.

That is a specific trade. The employer gives up one argument while retaining others. Angus identifies both the restriction and the attraction. It is useful to hear those things together, because a concession can otherwise arrive looking like an outbreak of institutional decency. Here, the audience gets to inspect the calculation before admiring the manners.

The blunt bastard also names the reputational attraction. That is the part worth keeping in view. A business can have a reason to stop fighting a point which has little to do with a sudden appetite for public accountability. Angus puts that possibility on the table himself, without requiring TCAP to supply a fucking decoder ring.


A Concession With Its Coat Still On

For someone bringing a claim, that makes a supposedly generous gesture easier to examine. Agreement about a disclosure can leave the central argument about its consequences very much alive. The tone of the correspondence might improve while the real contest barely shifts. A polite nod is worth precisely what it concedes.

That is why the viewer’s review is such a good little knife. Another commenter also praised the presentation’s usefulness to claimants. The audience could recognise the value of hearing how the other side approached these decisions. Angus was giving employers a seminar, but the explanations were available to everyone watching.

The joke therefore has a solid floor beneath it. A claimant can hear the commercial purpose of a choice, rather than merely receive the polished result in a letter. The profession usually charges handsomely for making its workings intelligible. The useful bastard has left this particular lesson on YouTube.


Horsfield Menzies Has Some Lovely Words

Meanwhile, Horsfield Menzies presents Angus as “calm, sensible and commercial”. His biography mentions “real people” and promises “creativity and empathy” in workplace disputes. It also stresses the client’s preferred outcomes. Those phrases deserve to be read together. The commercial destination is clear; the reassuring language provides the upholstery.

I gave that empathy a practical test. On 23 March 2025, I sent Angus, Simon Horsfield and Daniel Rubin a private complaint about Sam Butler. It raised alleged misuse of disability-related medical information, contact involving my medical centre, costs pressure and obstructive correspondence. I asked for an investigation and chased the following day.

No investigation outcome was communicated to me. That is what I put beside the brochure. My complaint gave the partners a chance to explain what their own firm had done and how they had examined it. Instead, the advertised empathy remained considerably easier to find on the website than in an account of the investigation.

What a fragrant little arrangement. Horsfield Menzies can describe the man in soothing terms while the person who complained is left without that outcome. The old recording supplies a particularly sharp soundtrack: Angus explaining why an employer might want an embarrassing argument to disappear from the contested ground. I would still welcome something more useful than scented bollocks about empathy.


Please Leave The Microphone On

Regular readers have already met Fungus explaining the economics of attrition in What a Relief!. This instalment adds an earlier, specific lesson about the calculation behind a concession. Meanwhile, the present-day sales pitch gives us something concrete to test: what does the reassurance amount to when his own firm faces a complaint?

That is where this series begins. We have the recording, the public biography and my account of the complaint sent directly to the partners. The sources can sit together without anyone turning the volume down. Angus has been generous enough to explain one side of the calculation. TCAP intends to keep asking about the other.

Do his partners ever wonder whether the bastard will finally button it? For their sake, somebody probably ought to find the mute button. For everyone else, this is excellent fucking television.

Lee Thompson – Founder, The Cummins Accountability Project


Sources

Scroll to Top