Gunnercooke – The Fungus Years : Angus Menzies And The Complaint That Became A Conduct Problem

At 37:32 in his gunnercooke whistleblowing webinar, Angus Menzies explains how an employer can sack a whistleblower and still win. A worker makes a protected disclosure, then keeps making accusations. If the tribunal accepts that the way the worker pursued them was the main reason for dismissal, the employer can defeat the automatic unfair dismissal claim. The whistle enjoys the full protection of the law. Would the poor bastard attached to it kindly hand in their pass?

This is why Fungus gets a series. In part one he explained why an employer might concede that a disclosure happened. Here he gives the boss a more interesting question: what, exactly, got the worker sacked? Watch his hands. The manager starts with a dismissal to explain. A quarter turn later, the worker has a pile of emails to explain.


Gunnercooke Opens The Workshop

Gunnercooke advertised Whistleblowing Claims and How to Defend Them on 22 November 2018. It named Angus as its employment law partner. The pitch was that employers could challenge weak claims and those with genuine merit should succeed. Fair enough. The pleasure of Angus is that he’ll take you round the back and show you what happens between those two clauses.

Take the school computer in one of his examples. An employee at Bolton School set out to demonstrate a security flaw. The school gave him a written warning for what it believed was unauthorised access. There you have two things you can tell apart: warning the school about the system and getting into the system to prove the point. No need for a single bloody adjective about the man who did it.

A minute earlier in the recording, Angus rules out one tempting bit of employer bollocks. If a protected disclosure really got somebody sacked, it won’t help the boss to say he misunderstood its legal status. But when Angus turns to the worker who kept making accusations, the ground is softer. The proposed second act may look remarkably like saying the first thing again. At 38:17 he draws attention to the scope employers have to get creative. Most partners would have left that bit in the speaker notes.


Four years later, in Kong v Gulf International Bank, the Court of Appeal upheld the rejection of a bank auditor’s whistleblowing dismissal claim. Yet Lady Justice Simler explained why the upset a disclosure causes is rarely something separate. Tell Legal there’s a problem with its paperwork and somebody in Legal may have a shit afternoon. Spoiling the afternoon isn’t necessarily a second act of misconduct. It rather comes with the audit.

Here’s the question I’d put to Angus’s audience. If the first email goes unanswered, what would you like the worker to do on Monday? Leave it, and the concern stays unanswered. Chase it, and you’ve got a second email. Nobody even has to delete the reason for the reminder. You can print the request, give yourself another column and write down what you think of the person who sent it.


Horsfield Menzies Supplies The Worked Example

My case concerned disability discrimination in recruitment. I didn’t get as far as the fucking interview, never mind a P45. On 23 March 2025 I wrote to Angus Menzies, Simon Horsfield and Daniel Rubin about Sam Butler. Why had their firm rung my medical centre about appointment availability, then used the answer to oppose a postponement? The practice hadn’t disclosed private information, the firm maintained. I still don’t remember listing the other side’s solicitors as my next of kin.

I chased the partners the next day. On 25 March Rubin closed further correspondence about allegations against his firm or its staff. He did, however, reserve the right to use my emails as “further evidence of your unreasonable conduct in these proceedings”. Lovely word, further. I still haven’t had an investigation outcome. My correspondence, on the other hand, already had a job. Your own correspondence is making for wonderful blog content a year later. Funny old fucking world, Mr Rubian.


What’s In The Next Column?

On 23 February 2026 Rubin sent the Tribunal Cepac’s strike-out material. The first evidence collection ran to 84 pages. Entry 46 reproduces extracts from my 25 March report to the Solicitors Regulation Authority, a separate document from my email to the partners. I asked the regulator to investigate Butler and hold Rubin accountable for his oversight. Beside the extract: Scandalous / Vexatious / Unreasonable / Disruptive / Abusive. Those are the firm’s classifications, not findings by the regulator.

Look again at the name on the email delivering my complaint about Daniel Rubin to the Tribunal as evidence about my conduct. Daniel Rubin. The postman was in the fucking letter.

The next entry is timed to the second: 02:37:47 on 26 March 2025. I asked the Tribunal to make Cepac spell out the allegations it wanted my case thrown out for. I also asked about redacting further medical records and urged the judge to reject Cepac’s application. The firm put one word beside the whole statement: Disruptive. What exactly was I supposed to disrupt by asking to see the case I had to answer? The fucking surprise?


What Angus Leaves On The Tape

After the hearing on 24 April 2026, Judge James struck out my claims and ordered me to pay Cepac £20,000. His decision rested on far more than that table. He relied on my correspondence and public posts, found my conduct unreasonable, scandalous and vexatious, and said my comments about the respondents’ solicitors lacked a reasonable foundation. Paragraph 180 records the consequence: no hearing on the merits. Newcastle decided how I’d pursued my case. It never decided why I didn’t get the interview.

Play the end of Angus’s example, then read paragraph 166. The judge distinguished my right to appeal or complain to the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office from the conduct he associated with it. Different legal question. Same little quarter turn. In the gunnercooke recording you can hear a solicitor explain it. In my file you can measure it with your finger: on page 18 I’m asking a judge for help; one column to the right, Cepac is offering that request as evidence that I’m the trouble.

Do his partners ever wish Fungus would button it? For once I’d like him to keep going. Angus, you had my email. Did anyone check why your firm rang my surgery, and what did they find? No need for another webinar. ‘Reply all’ will do.

Lee Thompson, Founder of The Cummins Accountability Project


Sources

Case file held by TCAP: Daniel Rubin’s email of 23 February 2026 and its attachment, Strike Out Evidence Part 1, PDF pages 16 to 18 (entries 46 and 47). The October TCAP article below reproduces extracts from the March correspondence and entry 46.

Scroll to Top